
President Obama wants some face time with the school children of the United States on Tuesday.
Seems pretty reasonable to me, seeing that he is the freely elected leader of the country and all. But to a particularly incensed part of the citizenry (whom I can only assume think Ronald Reagan was the cowboy messiah), allowing the American Chief Executive to speak directly to kids is unconscionable.
So what’s the uproar about? According to the NY Times, Obama has the gaul to think he can “urge students to work hard and stay in school.” What a jerk. Sounds downright criminal.
But, of course, if the situation is interpreted through the reality distortion field of fear politics, you wind up with conservative leaders, pundits, and parents convinced that Mr. President is out to corrupt the youth. You know, like the way Socrates did back in the olden timey days. Except Socrates wasn’t a black Indonesian Muslim communist illegally brought to power by a bunch of hippies to govern the Land of the Free. He was just an old philosopher making people question their flawed logic. But I digress.
Here’s some of the reasoning from Obama’s detractors:
- The speech wasn’t screened for political content. (reasonable)
- The speech wasn’t review by the school boards, which is mandatory for the curriculum. (also reasonable)
- “The thing that concerned me most about it was it seemed like a direct channel from the president of the United States into the classroom, to my child. I don’t want our schools turned over to some socialist movement.” (this man, naturally, will remove his children from school during the speech)
- He’s trying to create a cult of personality a la Saddam Hussein and Kim Jong-Il. (this was from a Rush Limbaugh guest, naturally)
- And then there’s this gem: “I wouldn’t let my next-door neighbor talk to my kid alone; I’m sure as hell not letting Barack Obama talk to him alone.” (oh boy…)
Even though the first two are “reasonable” (as in, a reasonable person could have developed those thoughts), they’re still not valid (and neither are the others):
- The speech won’t have political content; Obama and his speech writers are too smart to take that risk.
- The speech doesn’t need to be reviewed by the boards; he isn’t teaching…he’s giving a pep-talk.
- Anyone who knows what socialism is would know Obama is nowhere near being a socialist.
- Obama is like Hussein and Jong-Il? ¿Que?
- The President is the most monitored and controlled man on Earth. Every action he takes is finely tuned by a team of people who know how he should behave and what he should say. He wouldn’t say anything out of line to a child, nor would he attempt to indoctrinate one. Like I said in #1, it’s just not worth the political risk. And for crying out loud, it’s not as though he’s someone you’ll see on the next “To Catch a Predator.” Your neighbor, however, probably is.
Luckily, the United States is still primarily inhabited by sane people (and that includes most conservatives) who care about their children and know what a great opportunity this is for them. If there is anyone in the country that children should be able to look up to (besides their parents, of course), it should be the President. Instilling fear of the President in a child without any exceptionally good reason is shameful. And that is exactly what the few parents that are excluding their children from this experience are doing.
That said, if those parents just disagree with his politics, they should feel free to talk to their children about why they think he is wrong. And when they do, they should talk about the specific policies and stances that they believe he is wrong about. These are value discussions, and are incredibly important for helping children grow up with a proper sense of what good values are.
In other words, parents should play a major role in educating their children. It’s their job. It’s what Obama is hoping to make children yearn for. He’s not attempting to pollute their minds. He’s using his voice to encourage a universal good.
The most influential man on the planet is going to use his voice on Tuesday to be a cheerleader for growing up smart. It would be a travesty for any child in the USA to be deprived of his message for silly, hateful reasons.
Update: Here is the full text of Obama’s speech (released ahead of the presentation, no less). I don’t care who is delivering these words, no child should be kept from hearing them. Absolutely inspirational.
Recent Comments